Aviation accidents can have tragic consequences, resulting in serious injuries, deaths, and extensive property damage. When an aircraft crash occurs, complex legal questions arise regarding liability. A key issue is the potential responsibility of aircraft manufacturers for design flaws or defects that may have caused or contributed to the accident. This article examines the liability of aircraft manufacturers in aviation accidents.
Legal Framework for Manufacturer Liability
Aircraft manufacturers can face liability under both negligence and strict product liability legal theories. To prove negligence, victims must show the manufacturer failed to exercise reasonable care in designing and constructing the aircraft. Strict liability focuses on whether the aircraft had a defective condition making it unreasonably dangerous. Manufacturers can be liable even if they exercised reasonable care.
Plaintiffs typically pursue claims against manufacturers, arguing defects like faulty software, structural failures, flawed flight control systems, engine issues, or inadequate safety features caused the crash. Manufacturers often defend by blaming pilot error, improper maintenance, or intervening events outside their control. Establishing liability requires detailed investigations into complex aviation systems and operations.
High Legal Standards for Design Defect Claims
Courts apply stringent standards in evaluating whether an aircraft design is defective. Under government regulations, manufacturers must meet all requirements for airworthiness certifications. Compliance with the Federal Aviation Administration’s (FAA) extensive design criteria makes it difficult to prove a product defect.
Plaintiffs must present specific evidence that a feasible, alternative safer design would have prevented the crash. Courts recognize aircraft companies face difficult trade-offs between safety, cost, performance, and efficiency. Manufacturers are not obligated to incorporate all conceivable safety features. The key issue is whether the overall design was unreasonably dangerous given inherent risks in aviation.
No Strict Liability for Military Aircraft
The federal government has immunity from most lawsuits for accidents involving military aircraft. The Supreme Court ruled the government contractor defense shields manufacturers from strict product liability for design defects in military planes and equipment. Victims cannot recover against contractors for crashes of fighters, bombers, and other military aviation vehicles. However, manufacturers remain liable for negligence in production.
Pilot Error and Other Defenses
Aircraft manufacturers frequently escape liability by establishing pilot error or maintenance issues caused the crash rather than any product defect. Evidence of the pilot’s negligence, training failures, weather conditions, or a mechanic’s mistakes can defeat claims against the manufacturer. Defendants also argue no design feature could have overcome reckless, dangerous, or impaired piloting.
Manufacturers blame crashes on unforeseeable conditions outside their control, like bird strikes, unmarked obstructions, and airport facility inadequacies. Demonstrating the accident would still have occurred absent the alleged defect weakens plaintiffs’ cases. Settlements frequently occur to avoid unpredictable trial outcomes in these complex cases involving sophisticated technology and multiple issues.
A Challenging Area for Accident Victims
Victims of aviation crashes face an uphill legal battle in holding aircraft manufacturers responsible. The combination of stringent liability standards, government regulations, the blame-the-pilot defense, and other hurdles make these claims challenging. An experienced aviation attorney can critically assess whether product liability may provide a viable avenue for recovery. Thorough crash investigations and testimony from expert witnesses are crucial. Despite difficulties, manufacturers have settled and paid damages in cases with strong evidence implicating faulty designs.
Contact Our Experienced Aviation Lawyers
The aftermath of an aviation tragedy inflicts heavy burdens on grieving families. Our compassionate attorneys have successfully represented aircraft crash victims nationwide. If you lost a loved one in a crash potentially linked to manufacturer liability, contact our office for a free case evaluation. Our knowledgeable legal team will protect your rights while you focus on healing.
Call today to schedule a risk-free consultation on (415) 352-6264.
Or visit our office at 536 Pacific Avenue, San Francisco, CA 94133.